心理科学 ›› 2015, Vol. ›› Issue (2): 296-302.

• 基础、实验与工效 • 上一篇    下一篇

汉字部件水平的重复知盲效应

武悦,王爱平   

  1. 北京师范大学心理学院
  • 收稿日期:2013-11-26 修回日期:2014-04-11 出版日期:2015-03-20 发布日期:2015-03-20
  • 通讯作者: 王爱平

Repetition Blindness Effect on Processing Chinese Character Radical

  • Received:2013-11-26 Revised:2014-04-11 Online:2015-03-20 Published:2015-03-20
  • Contact: Aiping WANG

摘要: 本研究采用不同部件特点的汉字材料考察在汉字部件水平的重复知盲效应。实验1探究在一组刺激序列中,当两个关键刺激R1和R2的相同部件在不同位置时对重复知盲效应的影响。实验1结果表明,不同条件的重复知盲效应存在显著差异,但其中两个关键字中相同部件的位置相同时与部件位置不同时之间的重复知盲效应无显著差异,这表明部件位置对重复知盲现象无显著影响。实验2探究当关键刺激R1和R2为部件包含关系时的重复知盲效应。实验2结果表明,当一个关键刺激为独体字,且是另一个关键刺激的部件时存在重复知盲效应,其效应的大小会受到具有包含关系的两个关键字(合体字和独体字)在刺激序列中出现顺序的影响,当第二个关键刺激为独体字时的重复知盲效应要显著强于第二个关键刺激为合体字条件。研究结论是不同的汉字部件特点会影响重复之盲效应,这表明重复知盲现象很可能发生在在线的知觉加工过程。

关键词: 重复知盲效应, 汉字部件, 正字法, 知觉加工

Abstract: Repetition Blindness(RB)refers to the phenomenon that in a rapid serial visual presentation ,if there are two identical stimuli, the second repeated stimulus is difficult to be detected. There have been many studies about RB have been involved,such as the influential factors RB , The reason of occurring RB, and so on. Many hypothesis and theory about the cause of repetition blindness were put forward: Token individuation hypothesis, Type refractoriness hypothesis, Memory failure, ‘Construction / attribution’ framework and Competition hypothesis. Token individuation hypothesis, Type refractoriness and Competition hypothesis insisted that RB was a perceptual failure phenomenon in on-line processing, but Memory failure hypothesis suggested that RB was a phenomenon of off-line failure of memory, while the ‘construction / attribution’ framework thought that RB effect can happen during either perceptual processing or memory processing. RB can be found in many experimental materials, but the most common materials used in RB research were words. Some researchers have explored RB based on the characteristic of Chinese characters in China in resent years. The present study examined repetition blindness effect on the level of Chinese character radical. Chinese characters selected Chinese characters radicals with left-right structures or containing relationship were used as the experimental material in two experiments. Experiment 1 explored whether the position effect could affect RB effect if two key stimuli R1 and R2 shared the same radical. There were four experimental conditions: R1 and R2 were identical; R1 and R2 were different; the same radicals of R1 and R2 both were in same positions; the same radicals of R1 and R2 were in different positions. The result of experiment 1 showed that the repeated blind effect of the different conditions existed significantly differences, F(3,34)=19.78,p=0<0.01,η2 =0.64,but there is no significant difference between RB of identical position condition and different position condition, RB strength values of them, however, were significantly smaller than the identical conditions, and greater than the different conditions. Experiment 2 explored how robust RB effect was in the condition of two key stimuli R1 and R2 had a containment relationship. That one key stimulus, a single character, was the radical of the other, a compound character were used as the experimental materials in Experiment 2. The result of experiment 2 showed that the repeated blind effect of the different conditions existed significantly differences as same as Experiment 1, F(3,38)=53.02, p=0<0.01,η2 =0.81, and there was significantly more robust RB effect in the condition which R2 were the single characters, the radical of R1, than one which R2 was the compound character. But same as Experiment 1, RB strength values of R2, whether the single characters, or the compound characters, both were smaller than ones of the identical conditions, and greater than ones of the different conditions. The research conclusion was that the repetition blindness effect is affected by the different characteristics of the Chinese character radicals. It suggested that repetition blindness phenomenon is likely to occur in online perceptual processing.

Key words: Repetition Blindness Effect, Radical of Chinese Characters, Orthography, Perceptual Processing