Psychological Science ›› 2016, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (2): 485-489.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Memory suppression in healthy and depressive individuals

Yunzhe Liu2   

  • Received:2015-07-22 Revised:2015-12-28 Online:2016-03-20 Published:2016-03-20

记忆抑制在正常人群与抑郁人群中的研究进展

张丹丹1,柳昀哲2   

  1. 1. 深圳大学
    2. 北京师范大学认知神经科学与学习国家重点实验室
  • 通讯作者: 张丹丹

Abstract: Negative memory bias is one of the prominent cognitive deficits in depression. Previous studies mainly focused on the bottom-up selective attention to negative information in depressive individuals or the patients with depressive disorder. The influence of the top-down executive control deficit on memory has been largely ignored. Recent studies indicate that the deficit of memory suppression plays an important role in the formation and maintain of negative memory bias in depression. The main reason that depressive individuals persistently and negatively ruminate is that they cannot effectively perform motivated forgetting of negative events/stimuli. The relevant study will be of great importance in the improvement of the cognitive model of depressive disorder and the planning of therapeutic schedules for patients. The current mini-review introduced recent studies on memory suppression (or motivated forgetting) in healthy adults and in individuals with depressive disorder/tendency. In general, there are two stage of memory suppression, namely the encoding stage and the retrieval stage. As regard to the memory suppression on the encoding stage, directed forgetting paradigm is usually employed to compare the number of remembered items between to-be-remember and to-be-forget conditions. The effect of directed forgetting in healthy subjects is reflected by the performance in the posttest, which shows that the remembered items are more in the to-be-remember condition, compared with the remembered items in the to-be-forget condition. Recent studies in healthy adults revealed that the effect of directed forgetting is not only due to the mechanism of selective rehearsal, but also associated with the motivated forgetting in the memory encoding. As regard to the memory suppression on the retrieval stage, think/no think paradigm is usually employed to compare the number of remembered cue-target pairs between think and no think conditions. The suppression-induced forgetting can be observed when healthy subjects perform the think/no think task. In particular, the cue-target pairs in the no think condition are less frequently recalled in the posttest, as compared with the cue-target pairs in both the think condition and the baseline condition. Behavioral studies of memory suppression in depressive subjects have revealed that inhibitory control deficits exist on both memory encoding and retrieval stages. More specifically, three studies used directed forgetting paradigm found that compared with healthy controls, 1) individuals diagnosed with depression remembered fewer to-be-remember items while they forgot fewer to-be-forget items; 2) the patients remembered more negative than positive words in the to-be-forget condition; and 3) the impaired memory suppression for negative words was positively correlated with the severity of negative rumination. At the same time, three studies used think/no think paradigm found that the more severe the negative rumination, the worse performance of subjects in the no think condition. Furthermore, compared with healthy controls, depressive subjects remembered more emotional, especially negative, words in the no think condition. According to the current finding reviewed in this paper, we proposed three problems that need to be solved in this area and discussed possible solutions. It is suggested that directed forgetting and think/no think paradigms are employed simultaneously to explore the neural mechanism of the deficit of memory suppression in depression. Electroencephalogram and functional magnetic resonance imaging are appropriate techniques, which facilitate us to compare the spatial-temporal pattern of event-related potentials, event-related oscillations, and blood oxygen level dependent signals during the emotional memory suppression task in depressive individuals and healthy controls. In addition, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation is suggested to use in the experiment; it can stimulate specific brain region(s) so as to help illuminating the causality of specific brain region(s) in the deficit of memory suppression in depressive individuals.

Key words: depressive disorder, memory suppression, directed forgetting, think/no think paradigm

摘要: 抑郁症认知障碍的突出表现之一为患者的负性记忆偏向。已有研究常关注患者对负性信息自下而上的选择性注意,往往忽略了自上而下执行控制障碍对记忆的影响。近年研究提示,抑郁症患者和抑郁状态个体的记忆抑制缺陷在其负性记忆偏向的形成和维持中起到了重要作用,无法有效地主动抑制负性记忆可能是患者持续性负性反刍的主要原因。从抑郁症自上而下的执行控制缺陷入手,研究患者的记忆抑制障碍与其主要症状-负性反刍间的相关性,不仅能从理论上丰富Beck的抑郁症认知模型,还能指导临床建立更准确的预后评估指标,同时制定更有效的治疗方案。本文分别介绍了健康成人及抑郁症患者和抑郁状态个体的记忆抑制研究现状,并就当前在抑郁人群研究领域亟待解决的三个问题进行了探讨。

关键词: 抑郁症, 记忆抑制, 定向遗忘, 回想/不回想范式