Psychological Science ›› 2017, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (2): 485-491.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Initial Stage Item Selection Methods of CD-CAT

  

  • Received:2016-03-22 Revised:2016-09-20 Online:2017-03-20 Published:2017-03-20

CD-CAT初始阶段项目选取方法

高椿雷1,罗照盛2,郑蝉金1,喻晓锋1,彭亚风1,郭小军1   

  1. 1. 江西师范大学
    2. 江西师范大学 心理学院
  • 通讯作者: 郑蝉金

Abstract: Cognitive Diagnostic Computerized Adaptive Testing is a new testing mode which combines Computerized Adaptive Testing with Cognitive Diagnosis. It has the characteristics of adaptive and cognitive diagnosis, which can use less items and less time to evaluate knowledge state, it is applicable to classroom instruction because of timely and immediately evaluation. It is the basis of remedial teaching and students’ self-learning. It was presented by Thompson that CD-CAT had five important parts, they were parameter-calibrated and attribute-identified item bank, initial stage item selection methods, an item selection strategy, a knowledge stage estimation method and a stopping rules. Of which initial stage item selection methods can influence the pattern classification correct rate. It was only found through literature review that Tu, Cai, & Dai (2013) studied the initial stage item selection method, and presented “T matrix-method”, which selected initial items from R-matrix. The other initial stage item selection method was random method, which means that select first stage items from item bank randomly, this method does not consider item parameters and attributes. It is easy and fast. The research showed that T-matrix method had higher PCCR than random method. It is presented four initial stage item selection methods based on the discrimination of Cognitive Diagnosis, they are CTTID method, CDI method, CTTIDR* method and CDIR* method. 1) CTTID calculates discrimination based on identification index of Classical Test Theory, the fundamental question is “How well does this item help me to differentiate between respondents who have mastered “more” attributes and respondents who have mastered “fewer” attributes?” In DINA model, high discriminatory items are the items slipping and guessing parameters smaller. 2) CDI method is presented by Henson and Douglas (2005), which is a weighted average of the elements in D where the KLI values associated with attribute profiles that differ by one attribute have the highest weight and the KLI values associated with attribute profiles that differ by all A attributes have the smallest weight. 3) Reachability-matrix (R-matrix) was presented by Tasuoka (1995), it describes the direct, indirect and own relationships between attributes, and it is a matrix composed with K line * K column (K is the number of attributes). R* matrix is the necessary condition for testing to achieve diagnosing each attribute. Item parameter and R matrix are the important elements which can influence the efficiency of testing, so here we consider discrimination and R matrix simultaneously to select first stage items, CTTIDR* method is from this consideration. 4) A “good” item is one that discriminates well between respondents with different levels of ability, disposition, or another set of latent characteristics that are measured by a diagnostic assessment whose response data are modeled with a CDM. CDI is a good discrimination of CDM which can use in different models, CDIR* method is combined CDI with R* matrix. A simulation research was used to verify these methods of CD-CAT. CDM was DINA model, the number of examinee was 1000, item bank was 300, the number of attributes was 6. PCCR was the evaluation indices. The result showed that PCCR of CTTIDR* method was higher than existing T-matrix method with 0.2697 under fixed-length CD-CAT at the end of initial stage. When the testing finished, CTTIDR* method was also the best. The average testing length was also smallest under the variable-length CD-CAT.

Key words: CD-CAT, initial stage item selection methods, item discrimination

摘要: CD-CAT是CDA同CAT的相结合的产物,适用于课堂教学,是教师补救教学、学生自我学习的重要工具。作为CD-CAT重要组成部分的初始阶段项目选取方法是影响测验判准率的重要因素。本文基于现有研究和CDA的项目区分度提出了四种新的初始阶段项目选取方法:CTTID法、CDI法、CTTIDR*法和CDIR*法。通过模拟研究发现,在定长的CD-CAT下,题库质量是HD-HV下,初始阶段结束时,CTTIDR*法的PCCR比现有的T阵法高了0.2999,比PWKL高了0.1707,其它题库下趋势相同。整个测验结束时CTTIDR*法的判准率仍然是最高的。在变长的CD-CAT下,最大后验概率大于0.7、0.8、0.9下,CTTIDR*法的被试平均测验长度比T阵法分别缩短了2.6170、2.2347、1.7470道题。

关键词: CD-CAT, 初始阶段项目选取方法, 项目区分度