Psychological Science ›› 2012, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (4): 895-900.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

The content analysis of violence in popular teenage animations

1, 2, 2   

  1. 1. college of educaiton science, Henan University
    2.
  • Received:2011-07-30 Revised:2012-02-02 Online:2012-07-20 Published:2012-09-29
  • Supported by:
    supported by“the Humanities and Social Sciences Research Funds under the Ministry of Education for Youth"

初中生喜爱之动漫的暴力内容分析

范丽恒1,牛晶晶2,金盛华3   

  1. 1. 河南大学教育科学学院
    2. 河南山香文化科技有限公司
    3. 北京师范大学
  • 通讯作者: 范丽恒
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社会科学青年基金项目

Abstract: The violence in mass media has been a research focus of sociology and psychology. Many researchers paid more attention to the violence in movies and games, but neglected the violence in animations. This study examined the characteristics of violence that is perpetuating throughout popular teenage animations by content analysis method. In order to produce the representative sample, 596 middle school students were investigated by writing down the names of 10 preferable animations, and the top 3 animations were chosen from collected 98 animations based on frequency of nomination. Considering so many episodes in each animation, average 14 episodes from each animation were equidistantly selected as the research sample. After developing the contextual features coding schedule about the violence scene(mainly including the basic information of person involving in the violence, basic judgment about the cause and value of violence, relevant consequences of violence caused), 3 postgraduate students who were familiar with these 3 animations were trained as the research coder. they spent 7 weeks,6 episodes per week,to finish the coding. Results showed that the content analysis reliabilities which include intercoder agreement and constant reliability were almost higher than 0.8, and these animations contained a large proportion of violent scenes. Further analyses surfaced other defining characteristics of violence in the animations that appealed to middle school students, namely 1) many of the perpetrators of violence were teenagers, students and heroes, and they were mostly male and attractive; 2)the causations of violence were mainly helpfulness, performance of official duties, and violence was always for the sake of justice and could be forgivable; 3) violent scenes were usually depicted in close-up and they usually were not bloody; 4) much of the violence was unrealistic and lacking in humor; 5) there were inadequate descriptions highlighting the suffering of victims and a lack of sympathy shown towards victims as well; nevertheless, perpetrators of violence were rarely punished in spite of the scale of bodily harm caused. Therefore, it was concluded that the characteristics of violence in popular teenage animations were attractive perpetrators; justified, unrealistic and humorless violence; glamorized violence scenes; and trivialized the physical aggression.

Key words: violence in amimations, content analysis, junior middle school students

摘要: 为了更为深入地了解当前流行于青少年群体的动漫中存在的暴力内容的特点,本研究通过提名法选取了初中生最为喜爱的三部动漫影片,并采用质性的内容分析法对其暴力特点进行了分析,结果发现初中生最喜爱的三部动漫影片均为涉及较多暴力场景的动漫,且这些影片中的暴力特点主要表现为施暴者多为有魅力的英雄人物;暴力是正义的、非现实性的和缺乏幽默感的;对暴力场景进行较多的特写且较少出现血腥场景;很少描述受害者的痛苦和对受害者的态度;暴力往往会造成较大的身体伤害,但很少对施暴者进行惩罚。

关键词: 动漫暴力, 内容分析, 初中生